The Key Ingredient is one of three ingredients needed to make a Calming Potion for the Great Booga Shark. You can find it in the Temple Treasure Room of Shark Tooth Island, glowing on a pedestal.


  • It is unclear what is actually contained inside the Key Ingredient, and it looks like tea powder.
  • The other ingredients needed for the Calming Potion, along with the Key Ingredient, are the Old Bone and Carbonated Coconut Milk. This, along with hints of finding the Medicine Man, is carved on the wall of the Temple Treasure Room.
Shark Tooth Island logo transparent.png
Items Calming Potion | Carbonated Coconut Milk | Grass Skirt | Island Medallion | Key Ingredient | Old Bone | Shark Fin | Translation Key
Locations Ancient Ruins | Booga Bay | Castaway Island | The Medicine Man | Main Street (Coconut Cafe | Tourism Center | Shark Museum) | Temple Dungeon | Temple Entrance | Temple Treasure Room
Characters Booga Bay Fisherman | Coconut Milk Vendor | Distressed Mother | Female Explorer | Fruit Bat Man | Giant Caterpillar | Grass Skirt Vendor | Great Beast | Great Booga Shark | Male Explorer | Professor Hammerhead | Medicine Man | Native Islanders | Professor Pendulum | Randomized NPCs | Shark Boy | Shark Fin Vendor | Shipwrecked Boy | Tourist Info Lady | Tourist Lady
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.